Academic challenges to consensus on Russian blame
Anna Ivanova, a Kharkiv native at Justus Liebig University Giessen, argues that attributing all Ukrainian problems to Russian imperialism prevents the study of domestic failures. In an essay for the journal "Has Anything Gone Wrong in Ukraine?" published November 3, Ivanova claims that explaining all difficulties through Kremlin actions portrays Ukraine as "an object of geopolitical competition rather than a subject of its own history." Sociologist Volodymyr Ishchenko, a research affiliate at the Free University of Berlin’s Osteuropa-Institut, described the essay in a November 14 post on X as "a brilliant, wide-ranging essay on the ever more evident bankruptcy of the knowledge production on Ukraine." This challenge to the consensus that the war explains all country problems remains rare within the academic community. Ivanova notes that questioning the prevailing narrative often results in accusations of heresy rather than intellectual disagreement.
Economic decline and legal enforcement
Ukraine’s economic decline began well before the 2022 invasion. The country entered independence with a population of 52 million and a developed industrial base, yet the World Bank reports that GDP per capita stood at $4,775 in 2021. The share of industry in gross value added fell from 54.6% in 1991 to 23.2% in 2021, as aircraft building, power engineering, and the space industry disappeared, and the economy came to rest on raw materials exports and cheap labour. The World Bank also estimates that 41.6% of Ukrainians lived below the national subsistence line in 2025, which is double the 2021 rate. While successive governments prioritized national identity, a 2001 survey by the Kyiv International Institute of Sociology found that 76% of voters named the standard of living as a concern, compared to about 5% for the status of the Russian and Ukrainian languages.
Criminal prosecutions for communist symbols increased significantly following the full-scale invasion. Ukraine criminalised communist symbols with sentences of up to five years, just as most neighbors moved to administrative fines. Historian Georgiy Kasianov notes that prosecutions under Article 436-1 of the criminal code rose from 334 cases and 24 convictions between 2015 and 2021 to 896 cases and 307 convictions between 2022 and mid-2025. Of the 279 convictions where courts recorded social status, 124 involved unemployed or informally employed people, 84 involved pensioners, and 23 involved people with disabilities. These offences included wearing a hoodie bearing "USSR" or, in at least 21 cases, liking a social media post. In November 2016, Rating Group reported that 57% of Ukrainians opposed renaming towns and streets under 2015 decommunisation laws, while only 35% supported the move.
Ivanova describes language policy as "a form of class struggle" that imposes costs on those least equipped to contest it. Between 1991 and 1994, 56.2% of Ukrainians named Russian as their most comfortable language, and in 2023, about 80% of residents in Odesa and Kharkiv spoke it at home. The Constitutional Court declared Ukrainian "the code of the nation" in July 2021, and the commissioner for the protection of the state language questioned if people who have not switched to Ukrainian could be considered "homo sapiens." Additionally, the mayor of Ivano-Frankivsk supported language patrols.
