Politics

National Bank of Poland freezes Constitutional Tribunal accounts

The National Bank of Poland suspended all payment orders for the Constitutional Tribunal accounts following a dispute over legal representation. The freeze prevents the tribunal from paying staff and contractors amid a leadership struggle between judges.

National Bank of Poland freezes Constitutional Tribunal accounts

The Bank’s Freeze and the Financial Fallout

The National Bank of Poland (NBP) suspended all payment orders for the Constitutional Tribunal (TK) accounts on Monday, citing a set of documents that mutually cancel each other out. NBP spokesman Maciej Antes told the PAP news agency that no payment orders will be executed regardless of who initiates them. The bank cited doubts about the proper representation of the tribunal in its relations with the NBP. This freeze follows a letter from the suspended president of the tribunal, Bogdan Swieczkowski, to NBP governor Adam Glapinski. Swieczkowski asked Glapinski to block access to the accounts for the "usurpers" and requested to be the only person authorized to order payments. The new majority of judges, elected by the parliamentary majority this year, sent their own credentials to the bank to assert their authority. I find the NBP’s decision to pull the plug on the tribunal’s ability to pay its staff and contractors reckless in the face of a constitutional deadlock. The NBP said it is not the bank’s role to determine which side is legally entitled to represent the institution. Sources at the tribunal noted that interest is building up on unpaid bills to contractors, and staff still await their salaries. One person linked to the bank told Money.pl that when a doubt arises, you pull the plug. One person at the bank also remarked to Money.pl that power lies with whoever holds the salaries.

The Court’s Internal War

The leadership struggle involves eight judges elected to the TK this year, five of whom President Karol Nawrocki has refused to swear in. These judges took control of the court on October 30, when Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska took charge as the most senior judge and suspended Swieczkowski and his deputy, Bartlomiej Sochanski. The new judges declared that Swieczkowski and Sochanski failed to fulfill their duties and launched disciplinary proceedings against them. Swieczkowski called the takeover an illegal "coup d’etat" and claims the Supreme Court restored him to his position. On 10 November, the Supreme Court issued a ruling revoking the order to suspend Swieczkowski and Sochanski, though Korwin-Piotrowska says only the tribunal itself can decide on the issue. Swieczkowski sent the Supreme Court ruling to the NBP as evidence of his authority to manage the accounts, but he was turned away at the court’s gate two days after the ruling. Disciplinary hearings for Swieczczkowski and Sochanski are scheduled to begin later this week. This conflict follows a decade-long crisis where the government led by Prime Minister Donald Tusk refused to recognize the court’s legitimacy because three judges were unlawfully appointed under the former PiS government.

Tribunal Composition and Status Details
Total judicial seats 15
Judges elected this year 8
Judges refused oath by Nawrocki 5
Supreme Court ruling date 10 November

The Political Repercussions and Government Options

Finance minister Andrzej Domanski criticized the central bank for becoming embroiled in a political dispute, stating that the NBP should safeguard its independence. He told TVN24 that the government will explore all available options to secure funding so the tribunal can continue functioning. Justice minister Waldemar Zurek also condemned the NBP, saying that its invocation of a non-existent document to block funding for a constitutional body is an attempt to protect an entrenched system. The NBP governor, Adam Glapinski, who was appointed under the former Law and Justice government and remains a longtime associate of PiS leader Jaroslaw Kaczynski, must now navigate the fallout of a decision that pits his institution against the current administration. This standoff occurs while a parliamentary committee has recommended that President Nawrocki stand trial before the State Tribunal. The Tusk government ignored the TK’s rulings and refused to nominate new judges to fill vacancies on the 15-person bench until March of this year. However, Nawrocki has refused to accept the oath of most of those judges. Former NBP governor Hanna Gronkiewicz-Waltz, who is now an MEP for Tusk’s Civic Coalition, suggested that the state development bank BGK could step in to help.