Verbal promises lack substance
President Volodymyr Zelensky told reporters on Nov. 21 that he has yet to see written commitments outlining how proposed NATO-style security guarantees for Ukraine would work in practice. These remarks follow comments from U.S. envoy Jared Kushner, who said Washington was open to providing security guarantees modeled on NATO’s Article 5 collective defense provision during talks with European leaders in Berlin on Nov. 19. I find the current situation regarding these vague verbal assurances completely inadequate. Zelensky told the Kyiv Independent that Ukraine needs clarity on what "Article 5-like" commitments would actually entail. He asked who the collective would consist of and how they would defend Ukraine, and whether they would be prepared to repel the aggressor. "The answers must not simply be words, however eloquently they may sound, that ‘of course, nobody will abandon you.’ This must be on paper," Zelensky said. He added that he has not seen such commitments on paper.
The cost of independent defense
Ukraine needs guarantees that last for decades rather than two years. Zelensky noted that any security arrangement must remain effective beyond the time U.S. President Donald Trump holds office. If Ukraine does not join NATO, the country must maintain an army of around one million personnel alongside sufficient aircraft, artillery, missiles, and air defense capabilities to defend its territory independently. I think the prospect of maintaining such a massive force without NATO membership seems unsustainable for Ukraine’s budget. Zelensky argued that NATO membership would be cheaper for everyone because the alliance provides existing defense structures.
| Security Requirement | Details |
|---|---|
| Military Personnel | Approximately one million |
| Required Hardware | Aircraft, artillery, missiles, air defense |
| Guarantee Duration | Decades |
The 2024 Washington summit saw NATO allies reaffirm the path toward membership, but an invitation requires consensus among all members. Article 5 is the alliance’s collective defense clause, which requires all members to render immediate aid to any partner that comes under attack. Because an invitation needs agreement from all members, the outcome of Ukraine’s accession remains uncertain, depending on how and when the war with Russia ends. Zelensky reiterated that joining the alliance would both strengthen NATO and reduce the cost of Ukraine’s defense by providing existing security structures.
