Politics

Coalition talks to reset Polish Constitutional Tribunal stall

President Karol Nawrocki's attempts to reset the Constitutional Tribunal have stalled after the Polish People's Party and Poland 2050 failed to reach an agreement with other groups.

Coalition talks to reset Polish Constitutional Tribunal stall

Coalition split over tribunal reset

President Karol Nawrocki’s talks to reset the Constitutional Tribunal stalled on November 19 after the Polish People’s Party (PSL) and Poland 2050 failed to reach an agreement with other groups. Zbigniew Bogucki, head of the presidency’s chancellery, said the third round of talks was suspended. While all parties agree the current bench must go, they split over how to end the judges’ mandates. PSL and Poland 2050 are negotiating under a president backed by the opposition Law and Justice party, while Prime Minister Donald Tusk’s Civic Coalition and the Left boycott these sessions. I find these stalled talks a clear fracture in the governing coalition, as junior partners hedge towards compromise while the senior partner rejects it. At the Belweder palace meeting on November 16, PSL and Poland 2050 attended alongside PiS, Mateusz Morawiecki’s Rozwoj Plus, the far-right Confederation, Grzegorz Braun’s Confederation of the Polish Crown, Razem, and a Senate group. The parties are to send Bogucki fresh proposals next week.

The PSL constitutional amendment seeks to end the terms of all sitting judges and allows the National Assembly to elect a new 15-member bench. This plan requires a three-fifths majority for the election of new judges. The parties need a two-thirds majority in the Sejm to change the constitution, a figure that no single political camp can reach alone. During the second meeting on November 18, Bogucki noted they had agreed on about 70% of a single draft built on the PSL plan, which he called the most far-reaching option.

Tusk opposes mandate changes

Tusk, speaking in the Sejm on November 17, said he did not hold the talks against his partners and still trusted Kosiniak-Kamysz, but he would not move on the judges elected by the current parliament. He said the PSL reset is unlikely to prove realistic. The tribunal has seen two rival chiefs since late October, when Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska took charge and suspended the PiS-appointed president Bogdan Swieczkowski. Tusk saw off a no-confidence motion by 242 votes to 200, according to the Sejm’s voting record. This leadership dispute has already cost Poland three diplomats.

Voters remain split on the tribunal reset. An IBRiS poll for Rzeczpospolita taken on November 6 and 7 found 50.8% favored ending all current judges’ terms, while 39.9% opposed it. Among ruling-coalition voters, 49% opposed the change compared to 41% in favor. In a separate United Surveys poll for Wirtualna Polska, which asked specifically about the PSL proposal, 47.7% of respondents were against it and 44.2% were in favor, with 65% of coalition voters opposing it.