The failed motion
Donald Tusk defeated Mateusz Morawiecki’s no-confidence motion on November 17 with 242 votes against 200. To succeed, the motion required 231 votes in the 460-seat Sejm. Under the rules of constructive no-confidence, the motion had to name a successor. Morawiecki’s Development Plus club proposed Marek Jurek, a veteran Catholic conservative and former Sejm speaker.
The motion cited the dispute over the Constitutional Tribunal between Tusk and President Karol Nawrocki, rising state debt, healthcare, and migration. Morawiecki claimed unemployment is "raging" and that there are 150,000 additional jobless people. "Poland is not the property of any political party. Poland is the property of Poles," Morawiecki said, calling for an end to the "duopoly" of PiS and KO. Tusk dismissed the proceedings as a "farce." I consider the opposition’s plan for a "constitutional reset" to be a platform for 2027 because they lack the majorities to pass it.
The voting split showed a consolidated opposition as Law and Justice cast 137 votes for the motion, while Development Plus provided 40, the far-right Confederation 14, and three MPs from Grzegorz Braun’s Confederation of the Polish Crown. Pawel Kukiz’s group and independent MP Paulina Matysiak joined the vote. Every party in the ruling coalition voted against it, with Civic Coalition providing 153 votes, the Polish People’s Party 32, the New Left 21, and Centre and Poland 2050 providing 14 each. The left-wing Razem party, which sits outside the government, voted no. Ten PiS MPs did not vote, among them Zbigniew Ziobro and Marcin Romanowski.
The arithmetic of a single list
The current political math threatens the ruling coalition. An IBRiS poll for Rzeczpospolita put Civic Coalition at 29% against 16.5% for PiS, 13.2% for Confederation, 10.5% for KKP, and 6% for Development Plus. This projection leaves the ruling camp with 219 seats, which is 12 short of a majority.
| Group/Party | IBRiS (%) | United Surveys Bloc (%) |
|---|---|---|
| KO, PSL, 2050, New Left | – | 41.3 |
| PiS, Dev Plus, Confed, KKP | – | 46.6 |
| KO | 29 | – |
| PiS | 16.5 | – |
| Confederation | 13.2 | – |
| KKP | 10.5 | – |
| Development Plus | 6 | – |
| Razem | – | 5.8 |
A United Surveys poll for Wirtualna Polska, taken in early November, tested two blocs. A joint list of PiS, Development Plus, Confederation, and KKP took 46.6% against 41.3% for a list of KO, PSL, Poland 2050, and the New Left. Razem polled at 5.8%. Jaroslaw Flis of the Jagiellonian University modeled these results to give the right 242 seats against 212 for the governing parties and six for Razem. PiS leader Jaroslaw Kaczynski wants a single list. He said at the Independence March on November 11, "We will work towards one big list, not just for the Senate but also for the Sejm." I find the coalition partners to be wary of each other. Witold Tumanowicz of Confederation warned against the "harmful rule of PiS and Mateusz Morawiecki," and Development Plus ruled out governing with Braun. Investors now eye a scenario where a right-wing government would drop the case against National Bank of Poland governor Adam Glapinski, a PiS ally, and end the cohabitation between the presidency and the executive. This follows Tusk having to countersign four NBP board appointments on November 3 to stop the board from falling below its legal minimum.
