Politics

Supreme Court rejects government stance on Constitutional Tribunal

The Supreme Court ruled that Constitutional Tribunal judges must take their oath in the presence of President Karol Nawrocki to be valid. The decision also affirms that tribunal rulings remain binding even if Donald Tusk's government refuses to publish them.

Supreme Court rejects government stance on Constitutional Tribunal

The Supreme Court (SN) issued a resolution that rejects the government’s stance on the Constitutional Tribunal (TK) and supports President Karol Nawrocki’s position. I see the SN’s decision as a direct strike against the current administration’s attempt to control the tribunal’s validity. The SN found that a valid TK ruling can only be issued by a panel of judges who, after being elected to the tribunal by parliament, have "taken an oath before the president, that is, in his presence". This ruling affects five TK judges whom Nawrocki refused to swear in, even though they held ceremonies before a notary and sent their oaths to the presidential chancellery. While the administration and these judges claim this satisfies the requirement, the SN now endorses Nawrocki and TK chief justice Bogdan Swieczkowski’s view that the president must receive the oath in person. Nawrocki cited concerns over their qualifications to block eight new TK judges chosen by the parliamentary majority this year. Additionally, the SN ruled that valid TK rulings take force even if the government refuses to publish them. This addresses the refusal by Prime Minister Donald Tusk’s coalition to publish 85 rulings issued since March 2024 because they claim three judges were appointed under the former PiS government. Judge Aleksander Stepkowski stated that executive abuses cannot affect the "universally binding force of TK rulings" when the body responsible for publishing them fails to fulfill its obligation. However, justice minister Waldemar Zurek argues that the SN resolution is invalid because the judges were appointed through the politicised National Council of the Judiciary. Zurek wrote that any decision involving even one person appointed through the KRS after 2017 is a "non-existent judgement".

Chaos inside the Constitutional Tribunal

The tribunal remains in crisis as eight new judges chosen by parliament this year took control in late October. These judges announced they suspended chief justice Swieczkowski for failing to fulfill his duties. Swieczkowski, who has support from Nawrocki and SN chief justice Zbigniew Kapinski, calls this move an illegal "coup d’etat" and says he still leads the court. I find the situation extremely messy, especially since police prevented Swieczkowski from entering the building. On Wednesday, the same day the SN issued its resolution, the eight government-backed TK judges announced they lifted immunity from prosecution for Swieczkowski at the request of Zurek. This immunity lifting happened just as the tribunal’s internal leadership dispute intensified over who actually holds authority within the building.