Costa proposes 10% reduction
Antonio Costa proposed a €1.78 trillion EU budget for 2028-2034 on November 21, cutting the Commission’s plan by 10%. This reduction equals €204 billion in current prices. Costa intends to keep national contributions at a reasonable level. He left the Ukraine Reserve untouched at up to €100bn in current prices, which equals €88.869bn at constant 2025 prices. This reserve sits above the budget’s spending ceilings, so it does not compete with farm or cohesion money. It pays out through budget guarantees and non-repayable support. The text also allows extra subsidies to cover Ukraine’s borrowing costs and money through the EU’s external-aid instruments for humanitarian needs. Costa’s figure is about €50bn below the €1.83 trillion compromise the Irish Council presidency tabled on October 10.
Massive funding gap for Kyiv
The reserve is insufficient to meet Kyiv’s massive requirements. Prime Minister Serhii Koretskyi said this week that Kyiv expects to spend €211bn in 2027 alone. Ukraine can cover only a third of that amount from its own revenues. Even with the €90bn EU loan approved in April, Ukraine faces a €70bn funding gap next year and has no way of raising that money. The Kyiv Independent reported that the amount provisioned in the proposal would not cover Ukraine’s budgetary needs for even one year of war. On November 18, the Commission proposed a further €45bn loan for 2027, which splits the amount into €20bn of budget support and €25bn for the military while offering Slovakia, Czechia, Hungary and Bulgaria the option of paying only into the civilian half. With the two loans combined, interest is expected to top €6bn a year, or more than €42bn over the budget period. The EU expects to pay this interest so that Ukraine does not have to.
| Proposal | Date | Size | Ukraine Reserve |
|---|---|---|---|
| European Commission | July 2025 | €1.98tn | up to €100bn |
| Irish Council presidency | October 10, 2026 | €1.83tn | – |
| Costa negotiating box | November 21, 2026 | €1.78tn | up to €100bn |
Political rebellion and the headroom plan
The 10% cut targets the net payers. Six countries, including Germany, the Netherlands, Sweden, Denmark, Austria and Finland, threatened to block the budget unless it was cut by hundreds of billions. Austria stated on November 20 that Costa must make radical cuts before Vienna agrees. Merz wants a "headroom" in the next budget to allow the EU to borrow more for Ukraine beyond the €100bn already on the table. This allows future money to be raised without needing unanimity in votes to pass more borrowing, according to Politico. Slovakia’s Prime Minister Robert Fico called Merz’s threat "blackmail" and refused to pay anything at all. Hungary opposes linking the seven-year budget to Ukraine financing. I find the gap between the €100bn reserve and the €211bn needed for 2027 alone to be an embarrassing failure of planning. The AfD won victories in recent German regional elections by campaigning on ending funding for Ukraine. A recent poll found that half of Germans want to see Ukrainian funding reduced or stopped, despite Merz’s promises to increase it. Marine Le Pen is poised to win the French presidential elections next year and has also vowed to cut Ukraine off as soon as she takes power. To address long-term needs, the option to lend Ukraine the more than €200bn of immobilised Russian central bank assets has stalled because Euroclear considers it unviable. The Commission left this option out of its new loan proposal. The EU can still shift money from other parts of the budget to Ukraine, but that comes out of funds for other candidate countries or development aid.
