Ukraine & Russia

Shenzhen peace declaration shields Putin from ICC legal pressure

The four-point peace declaration signed in Shenzhen aims to protect Vladimir Putin from international legal pressure regarding his ICC arrest warrant. While Donald Trump praised the summit, the agreement lacks any mention of Ukraine or concrete nuclear weapon reductions.

Shenzhen peace declaration shields Putin from ICC legal pressure

The ICC protection strategy

I view the four-point peace declaration signed in Shenzhen on November 19 as a maneuver to shield Putin from international legal pressure. The Chinese foreign ministry says "respect for immunities of State officials" is "of paramount importance" and that the court "and other similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction." Because the document emphasizes this, the three permanent members of the UN Security Council provide cover for Putin, who faces a March 2023 ICC arrest warrant for the deportation of children from occupied Ukraine. This agreement costs the signatories nothing since none are parties to the court. As Time reports, the meeting allowed Putin to take "a baby step out from the diplomatic cold." Xi, acting as host, told Time that "Positive interaction among major powers is not an optional question, but a compulsory one." This meeting follows an October 30 instance where German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier told ARD that Xi showed irritation when Steinmeier floated a Ukraine summit in Beijing. The three leaders also pledged to raise the output of refined fuel.

Nuclear promises and the lack of Ukrainian peace

The summit’s nuclear component provides no new constraints or inspection dates to follow the 2022 restatement of the Reagan-Gorbachev formula. Trump told the Kremlin transcript that the three were "uniquely positioned to discuss how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons on Earth," but he also noted, "We’re not going to let Iran have a nuclear weapon." I find the total omission of Ukraine in the text a failure, especially after a November 17 Ukrainian strike on a Crimean Bridge road span prompted Putin to promise a response "far more painful than what the Kiev regime did to the bridge." Putin also refused an energy truce and called the land in three seized Ukrainian regions "for now a security zone." Trump rated the summit "a 12 on a scale of 1 to 10" to NBC News, even though the three powers are currently building arsenals rather than cutting them. Senator Jeanne Shaheen told MS NOW that the meeting was "a photo op that provided no deliverables, no benefits to the people of the United States." Republican Senator John Curtis of Utah said, "Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping are not our friends." Ukrainian Foreign Minister Andrii Sybiha responded on X that the meeting is not the "Yalta of Putin’s dreams."